For more access to expert legal analysis, official court documents and breaking news coverage only available here at the intersection of law and politics, please consider becoming a paid subscriber.
Attorneys Brian Kabateck and Shant Karnikian expose Trump's absurd plan to spend a billion taxpayer dollars converting Alcatraz Island from a profitable national park back into a prison, despite the facility generating $60 million annually in tourism revenue. They reveal how this medieval spectacle would violate the Eighth Amendment's cruel and unusual punishment clause, as the crumbling 1963-era facility lacks running water and has suffered decades of salt water damage that makes it uninhabitable by modern prison standards. The hosts break down the legal impossibility of Trump's scheme, which would require Congress to strip Alcatraz of its National Historic Landmark status and remove it from the National Park System—all to house maybe 300 prisoners at astronomical cost. They examine how this wasteful boondoggle represents Trump's broader war on California and his reality show presidency, where billion-dollar stunts matter more than practical governance. A devastating look at how Trump's "law and order" posturing leads to the most inefficient government waste imaginable, proving that when authoritarian theatrics meet fiscal responsibility, taxpayers always lose.
Share this post